Equity was never designed to cross a border.
Benchmarking a salary is straightforward and widely available. Giving a subsidiary’s leadership genuine ownership, when the parent’s equity plan was written for a different jurisdiction and a different tax code, is the harder question — and the one that decides retention.
A plan that works at headquarters frequently means nothing at the centre.
Parent-company equity is granted in a foreign currency, vests against a share price the holder cannot influence, is taxed on a schedule the holder did not choose, and is often administered on a platform they cannot access in their own language. It is technically ownership. It is rarely experienced as ownership — and an instrument that is not felt does not retain.
The four structures, and what each actually does.
| Instrument | What the holder receives | Dilution | Typical fit | Principal difficulty |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| ESOP — parent shares | Actual equity in the parent | Yes, at parent level | Senior leadership; listed parents | Currency, tax timing, perceived remoteness |
| ESOP — subsidiary shares | Equity in the Indian entity | Yes, at subsidiary level | Where a future transfer or listing is contemplated | Valuation, illiquidity, exit mechanism |
| Stock Appreciation Rights | Cash equal to appreciation over a base | None | Broad leadership population | Cash liability at settlement; accounting treatment |
| Phantom stock | Cash tracking notional share value | None | Where equity is impossible or undesirable | Credibility — it must be governed like real equity |
The selection is rarely one instrument. It is usually a layered position — one structure for the executive population, another for the critical technical population, and a cash long-term incentive beneath both.
What Pillar II delivers.
- Reward Philosophy and Positioning
Where the centre chooses to sit in its market, by band and by capability, and the argument that defends that position against both internal pressure and competitive movement. A philosophy that cannot survive a budget cycle was never a philosophy.
- Pay Architecture
Ranges, progression logic and the mechanics of movement, aligned to the grade and band structure from Pillar I. Built to withstand statutory structure requirements and to hold together when the market moves faster than the plan.
- Equity Instrument Design
Selection, structuring and governance of the instrument — vesting, performance conditions, valuation approach, settlement mechanics, and the cross-border tax consequence for both entity and holder.
- Pay Transparency Position
Gender-neutral job classification, defensible equal-value comparison, and the data architecture required to answer an information request or produce a gap report without a fire drill.
- Governance and Communication
Plan governance, administration, and the communication without which any instrument is functionally worthless. An unexplained grant is a cost to the company and a puzzle to the recipient.
The Pay Transparency Directive is now live, and the centre is part of the group position.
Where transposition stands
The deadline has passed and implementation is fragmented. Only a small group of member states — among them Italy, Slovakia, Lithuania and Malta — had complete legislation in force on the date. Germany, France, Spain and the Netherlands did not; several have signalled 1 January 2027. Sweden has paused pending renegotiation. Meanwhile the underlying directive already shapes legal risk, and data collection for the first gap reports, due June 2027, is underway.
What the centre must support
Pay ranges disclosed early in recruitment. A prohibition on asking candidates about pay history. Pay secrecy clauses void. A right for any worker to receive written information on their own pay and on average pay for comparable work, broken down by sex. Gap reporting on base and variable components. Where an unjustified gap of five per cent or more is unremedied, a joint pay assessment follows.
What is handed over.
- Reward philosophy with market positioning by band
- Pay architecture with ranges and progression logic
- Equity instrument selection with structuring rationale
- Plan documentation, vesting and settlement mechanics
- Gender-neutral job classification supporting equal-value comparison
- Pay data architecture for information requests and gap reporting
- Communication programme and plan governance framework
